Margaret
Thatcher and her impact on the people of Essex was the centre of national
debate after the 1993 general election, when one of the first constituencies
to declare, Basildon, did so for the Conservatives, and which signalled
yet another Labour party defeat. There seemed an unbreakable affinity
between much of the Essex population and the Tories.
Author Michael Collins comments,
‘This
development revived fears that the working class were forsaking community
for individualism. Instead of living behind the same cobalt-coloured
door as all their neighbours, they were choosing their own, and maybe
adding a pane of glass with a rain-effect and a brass doorknob. The
concern now appeared to be not that the owner-occupiers from the working
class might become bourgeois, but that they might not. They were becoming
something far worse, apparently – the lower middle class…
Now the terms “Essex Man” and “Thatcher’s children”
became shorthand for those who moved into the suburbs and made it into
the middle class via new money…’(1)
It is important
to assess the impact of Thatcherism on Harold Hill and to review how and
why she rose to power.
Margaret Thatcher, born Margaret Hilda Roberts in 1925, remains a pivotal
Conservative politician in British history. Indeed, she was a Prime Minister
whose authority and influence over the course of the twentieth century
is equal to that of other Prime Ministers such as Lloyd George, Clement
Atlee and – in a comparison that would thrill her – Winston
Churchill.
Born in Grantham in the East Midlands, her father, Alfred Roberts, was
a shopkeeper who had held office as an Independent councillor for 16 years,
including for a period as alderman and mayor. Particularly active in the
Wesleyian Methodist church, he was more Conservative than Liberal.
Margaret Roberts grew up in the strata called the middle middle class.
It was a spartan, strict upbringing that would see the whole of Sunday
donated to at least four separate church services.
It is these roots that help explain her later political philosophy –
a celebration of the work ethic, as opposed to receiving state benefits;
individual hard work, rather than the collectivism and group solidarity;
marriage and family, rather than divorce or single parenthood.
As she herself later remembered:
‘You
were taught to work jolly hard, you were taught to improve yourself,
you were taught self-reliance, you were taught to live within your income,
you were taught that cleanliness was next to godliness, you were taught
self-respect, you were taught always to give a hand to your neighbour,
you were taught tremendous pride in your country, you were taught to
be a good member of your community.’ (2)
Although
in the seventies and eighties Margaret Thatcher announced that her ideas
were inherited from her father, in truth, like any intelligent woman,
she took some and abandoned others. Indeed, she would only really refer
to her father’s influence after arriving in 10 Downing Street -
upon leaving home at 18 she saw very little of him or Grantham ever again.
A bright but unassuming student, she joined Oxford as an undergraduate
studying chemistry. The most notable aspect of her time there was becoming
active in the Oxford University Conservative Association.
After graduating she spent years as a research assistant but that was
merely a backdrop to her greatest passion: politics. In the 1950 and the
1951 general election she stood as the Conservative parliamentary candidate
for Dartford, after which she married Denis Thatcher and forever lost
her maiden name of Roberts. By now she had transformed herself, as one
of her contemporary college students remembered after a 1953 reunion:
‘She
had lost the Midlands accent that her fellow students had known. Now
she sounded more like Princess Elizabeth, who was not yet Queen…
Princess Elizabeth used to talk of ‘May Husband and Ay’,
which was quite a joke among our… generation. To our surprise
Margaret, newly married, now said just that and we, her contemporaries,
felt ashamed that one of us could be so embarrassing. She then gave
us her views on marriage and home life expressed in such sanctimonious
platitudes that we were even more embarrassed to be associated with
her.’ (3)
Margaret,
‘the Grocer’s Daughter’, made much play of her humble
beginnings, especially after becoming Prime Minister in 1979. Although
leading an austere childhood, Thatcher had never experienced poverty,
indeed, she quickly became accustomed to luxury, moving on from Oxford
University she married into wealth and became the MP for Finchley in 1959.
Living in Chelsea, her two children were sent to Britain’s most
prestigious public schools. Later, she would repeatedly make claim to
her modest beginnings without also being so candid to admit that she was
married to a millionaire and presided over a Cabinet of millionaires.
She was an anti-intellectual, a gut politician whose own arrogance and
self-righteousness found, for a period, an affinity with much of the British
electorate. A humourless, disciplined woman who impressed (and repulsed)
countless acquaintances throughout her life with her absolute confidence
and self-assuredness in both her own ability and the rightness of her
mission. Towards the end of her Premiership this unflagging self-belief
was perceived by many as a form of madness.
Although she won many admirers over her long rise to power, she always
alienated many other fellow Conservatives. Chris Pattern recalls her voice
being ‘rather like a friendly dentists drill’
; Peter Rawlison remembers her incessant chatter: ‘How
she talked!… I believe she honestly did not realise how irritating
she was.’; another colleague remembers that ‘At
moments I thought she was nothing but ice; I never felt there was any
warmth at all.’(4)
Nevertheless, her detractors grudgingly admired her as an extremely committed
and passionate politician.
In October 1961 she was invited to join the government as Parliamentary
Secretary at the Ministry of Pensions and National Insurance – the
youngest woman to have gained ministerial office. Although Labour resumed
government in 1963, whilst in opposition she took a succession of portfolios
which is a measure of her ability to get to grips with any new responsibility
on any subject.
Gradually, throughout the Sixties, she built a limited but steady reputation
as an MP who was decisive and thorough. Politically, she was identified
with the rightwing of her party, but never greatly so. In the 1966 election
campaign the features of her politics which she chose to emphasis were
tighter industrial relations laws, the defence of grammar schools and
greater home-ownership, about the last of which she declared ‘These
are fresh fields to conquer’(5) .
After the surprise Tory general election victory of 1970 she was appointed
Secretary of State for Education and Science – a post she held for
almost four years. Here, she exhibited little of the political doctrine
to be called Thatcherism other than gaining the nickname of ‘Thatcher
the milk snatcher’ for taking away free milk from schoolchildren.
Her time was yet to come – and that started after the Conservative
election defeat of 1974 amidst widespread economic and social chaos.
The later political ideas of Thatcher were a reaction to the consensus
that came after the war. The Labour Party won an historic victory in 1945
and immediately set about implementing a programme of nationalisation,
house building and expansion of the welfare state.
The Conservative Party was happy to follow in the footsteps of Labour
as prosperity for all seemed the key to stability - the economy in the
fifties and sixties was the most buoyant in British history.
Full employment, now a distant memory, gave way to a rise in consumerism
and the mass usage of television, washing machines and annual holidays.
The Tory Prime Minister, Macmillan, famously announced in late 1959 that
‘you’ve never had it so good’
with the Evening Standard editorial declaring on New Years Day
1960 that we had all arrived in an ‘Age of Plenty’:
‘The
age of scrimping is over. The age of affluence has begun. In the past
10 years Britain has passed through a social revolution whose full impact
is only likely to be felt in the new decade that has just begun. For
the first time in history the greater part of this country's people—and
not just the fortunate minority—have money to spare beyond their
immediate needs.’
By the
1970s the economy began to shudder and then decline, unemployment rose
to Depression-era levels, industrial relations were fractured and the
nation had a deep-seated fear of crime and immigration.
Where there was once peace and love in the sixties, now there was a
Clockwork Orange, violence on the terraces and loose talk of a military
coup in the officers’ mess.
From the late 1960s onwards there was a growing counter-revolution against
post-war Conservative orthodoxies. Lead by Enoch Powell, this faction
was increasingly vocal in calling for the privatisation (then called denationalisation)
of major industries, tax cuts and laws to restrict trade unions.
Disgraced by his 1968 anti-immigration speech, Powell was banished permanently
to the obscure political hinterlands, and in his place came to prominence
Arthur Seldon, Alan Walters, Geoffrey Howe and Keith Joseph who were right-wing
prophets for the new Tory age.
Against all expectations, in 1975 Margaret Thatcher beat Edward Heath
to become the Leader of the Opposition. The subsequent years, from 1975
to 1979, were a good grounding in experience rather than a triumphant
success. In parliament, she failed to leave a mark as Leader of the Opposition,
but at the annual Tory conference she shone with confidence.
The latter success a reflection of the increasing evangelical zeal found
amongst the rank and file of a party with Thatcher at its head.
Her real saving grace though was the so-called ‘Winter of Discontent’
in 1978/9 when a series of public sector strikes met with howls of outrage
from the press –the Labour Party subsequently became associated
with industrial unrest and chaos for the next 20 years.
Thanks, in part, to media-savvy campaigning the Conservative Party won
the 1979 general election with 44 per cent of the vote. Upon victory,
on the steps of Downing Street, she famously quoted a prayer of St Francis:
Where
there is discord, may we bring harmony;
Where there is error, may we bring truth;
Where there is doubt, may we bring faith;
And where there is despair may we bring hope.
The Right
to Buy – as selling council homes become known – had for a
number of years been an important plank of the Tory platform, although
Margaret Thatcher rarely showed much enthusiasm for the policy until its
popularity amongst the people became evident later on.
By the time of the 1974 general election she wrote and distributed a circular
letter to Conservative candidates outlining policy. In reply to the rhetorical
question ‘Why should council tenants be allowed to buy their houses?’
she answered,
‘Everybody
wants to own their home, because of the security and pride of ownership
that a house-owner enjoys. Also, people who have bought their own homes
have benefited over the years from increases in house prices—while
people who have lived in council houses or flats have nothing to show
for all the rent they have paid.’
To the
question ‘The price… (is) below market value. Is this justified?’
she replied,
‘The
justification from the ratepayer's and taxpayer's viewpoint is that
he is already paying out revenue subsidies in respect of council houses,
and would continue to do so if the house remained rented. Further, the
maintenance costs are transferred to the tenant. If he becomes a home
owner it is possible that his own family will then think of buying a
home when the time comes, instead of going on to the council waiting
list. Finally, bearing in mind that about 70%; of council houses were
built before 1964, when building costs were very much lower, the buyer
is still paying a lot more than historic cost, and the profit will accrue
to the local authority.’ (6)
In fact,
money from the sale of council houses was ‘ring-fenced’ and
not spent. By the time of the 1979 general election she was once again
explaining the Conservative housing policy, this time on the television
programme TV Eye:
‘They
might just as well have the chance to buy it when they're comparatively
young, and then they'll know that after twenty-five years or so, they
won't have to pay any more rent… ’(7)
In truth though, she was initially hostile to the idea of discounts to
tenants wanting to buy their own homes - she worried that it was unfair
to all the other homeowners who were paying full price. Eventually, as
the years passed and the massive political capital from the policy became
apparent, Margaret Thatcher cooed warmly of, what she called, popular
capitalism:
‘In
about twenty-five years’ time there will be quite a lot of people,
who will be inheriting something, because for the first time we will
have a whole generation of people who own their own homes and will be
leaving them, so that they topple like a cascade down the line of the
family, leaving to others not only their houses but some of their shares,
some of their building-society investments, some of their national-savings
certificates – only on a bigger scale than ever before.
The overwhelming majority of people, who could never look forward to
that before, will be able to say: ‘Look, they have got something
to inherit. They have got the basis to start on!’ That is tremendous.
That is popular capitalism.’(8)
After
the 1979 general election the Tories had a 43-seat majority, by the 1983
general election that had gone up to 144, despite of one of the worst
economic depressions this country has ever seen.
There were three things that saved the first Conservative government:
the Falklands war, North Sea oil and the selling of council housing stock.
The revenue from North Sea oil paid for the unemployment and housing benefit
for those out of work; the Falklands War in 1982 ushered in a period of
nationalism unseen since the Second World War, while the 500,000 dwellings
sold by ’83 at give-a-way discounts ensured an added bonus of electoral
support, mainly from the skilled working-class.
And that support from some sections of the working class were crucial.
Consecutive budgets cut back public spending, prescriptions increased
five-fold over a one year period, sickness and unemployment benefit were
subject to income tax, in effect, cut; further education funding was slashed.
What’s more, the inner-cities erupted into riots that shocked the
nation. Firstly, Brixton went up in flames, followed in July 1981 by Toxteth
in Liverpool and over the next few weeks Manchester, Birmingham, Blackburn,
Bradford, Leeds, Derby, Leicester and Wolverhampton: 'One colleague observed,
‘the Prime Minister’s nerve seemed momentarily
to falter.’ Political opponents she could deal with, but
widespread civil insurrection might destroy her. On television she looked
unusually nervous…’(9)
In July there was also the wedding of the century when Prince Charles
and Diana married, while as a soundtrack to rioting and Royalist fervour
the reggae song Ghost Town was number one in the charts:
‘This
town, is coming like a ghost town
Why must the youth fight against themselves?
Government leaving the youth on the shelf
This place, is coming like a ghost town
No job to be found in this country
Can't go on no more
The people getting angry’
Echoing
the opinions of politicised ska bands, the late and influential Romford
Recorder journalist, Roy Weal, was writing that,
‘Hundreds
of Havering teenagers will form an army of jobless kids when they leave
school this summer.
Many of them face a miserable life as “no hopers” when they
step out of the school gates for the last time. This picture is one
of desperation with youngsters facing a dead-end situation: NO work;
NO education; NO money.’(10)
If the
soundtrack to 1981 was reggae, Royalty and riots, then the build-up during
the previous summer– when Maggie came to Harold Hill - resounded
to the sounds of another Two Tone band, The Beat, and their rousing sing-a-long
anthem, Stand Down Margaret:
‘I
said I see no joy
I see only sorry
I see no chance of your bright new tomorrow
So stand down Margaret
Stand down please
Our lives seem petty in your cold grey hands
Would you give a second thought
Would you ever give a damn, I doubt it
Stand down Margaret
Everybody shout it
Stand down Margaret!’
Whilst
this song was in the charts, Prime Minister Thatcher and a gaggle of pressmen
came to the estate. The occasion for the visit was to see the Patterson
family of 39 Amersham Road who were to be the 12,000th household in the
country to buy their house under the new housing legislation.
They had lived at their three-bedroomed, semi-detached house for 19 years,
and purchased it for £8,315 after being given a 47 percent discount.
After enjoying a cup of tea and an inspection of their house she decamped
to the front lawn where in front of dozens of journalists she ceremoniously
handed over the deeds of the house. Questioned whether it was sensible
to remove the home from the housing pool when there were currently 3,305
families on the waiting list in Havering, she declared:
“Many
council tenants live there for the rest of their lives. The house is
already off the market, why shouldn’t they have a chance to buy
and hand something on to their children? Why shouldn’t they have
the chance to become little capitalists?
“Mr. and Mrs. Patterson have put a lot of work into this house
and it is better for it. They should have the chance to benefit.”
(11)
Echoing
the sentiments of many who brought their house from the council, Mrs.
Patterson said, ‘We felt we couldn’t
turn down a marvelous bargain.’ (12)
Not long after, the Patterson
household fell behind on repayments to the mortgage company, their marriage
fell apart, and the house was repossessed.
(1)
Michael Collins, The Like Of Us: The Biography of the White Working Class.
Granta, 2004.
(2) Margaret Thatcher, The Times, 16/04/83
(3) Margaret Thatcher: The Grocer's Daughter. Campbell, John,
p.98
(4) Margaret Thatcher: The Grocer's Daughter, Campbell, John,
p.176
(5) Finchley Press, March 25, 1966
(6) Circular letter to Conservative candidates. September 25, 1974
(7)TV Interview for Thames TV Eye, April 24, 1979
(8) Margaret Thatcher, The Times, 28/03/86
(9) Margaret Thatcher: The Grocer's Daughter, Campbell, John,
p.114
(10) Romford Recorder,
Spring, 1981
(11) Romford Recorder, August 15, 1980
(12) Romford Recorder, August 15, 1980